Every weekend, I watch the same scenario unfold.
A young referee – 15, maybe 16 years old – walks onto the pitch. Recently trained, nervous as hell, giving up their weekends so your child can play football. They’re hesitant with decisions. They don’t blow the whistle with confidence. They go with the shout because they’re still learning what match control actually feels like.
And you, standing on the touchline, you deal with it. Initially.
You understand they’re new. You bite your tongue when a throw-in goes the wrong way. You remind yourself they’re just a kid learning. You are, in that moment, fairly rational.
Then comes the flashpoint.
A challenge in the box. A potential penalty. The young ref bottles it or gets it wrong or doesn’t see it the way you do. And something shifts. You stop being a parent/carer/guardian (PCG – Danny told me to use this term) watching their child play football. You become a football supporter. That emotion turns, and you explode.
I’ve seen it hundreds of times. That transformation happens in seconds. The rational person you were thirty seconds ago is gone, replaced by someone screaming at a teenager about competence, bias, fairness—whatever justification your anger reaches for in the moment.
And here’s what you don’t realise as you’re losing it: you’ve just given every other PCG permission to do the same.
One person exploding has a catalytic effect. The touchline was tense but controlled. Now it’s not. Other PCGs join in. The ones who were biting their tongue don’t need to anymore. You’ve shown them it’s acceptable. Within minutes, that 15-year-old is managing not just a football match but a crowd of adults who’ve decided a children’s game justifies screaming at a child.
Let me be clear about something: the game needs these young referees. Without them, grassroots football ends. There aren’t enough experienced refs to cover every U12s match on a weekend. These nervous teenagers stepping onto the pitch? They’re not a luxury. They’re not optional. They’re essential. And you’re driving them away.
But this isn’t just about the PCGs who explode.
This is about the rest of you.
You saw it happen at the U11s match last Saturday. You felt your stomach drop when that dad started screaming. You looked at your shoes. You checked your phone. You turned to talk to another PCG about something, anything else. You felt uncomfortable, but you said nothing.
You’re not innocent because you didn’t shout. You’re complicit because you allowed it.
The club official who watched it happen and didn’t intervene. The coach who saw their player’s PCG lose control and stayed silent. The league administrator who receives the match report and files it away without consequence. Every single one of you is part of the system that enables this.
That young referee doesn’t distinguish between the person screaming at them and the thirty people who watched it happen and did nothing. To them, you’re all part of the same problem. You’re all adults who decided that their dignity was less important than avoiding confrontation.
Here’s something that should make you deeply uncomfortable: the FA has achieved record retention rates. 80% of referees are staying in the game. Numbers are up 20% to over 37,000 officials. Institutional support is working.
And 98% of them experience verbal abuse.
Read that again.
We’re celebrating that young people can now withstand abuse better. We’ve built support structures that help teenagers cope with being screamed at by adults. We’ve normalised severe abuse as the baseline experience of grassroots officiating and decided that’s fine as long as retention rates improve.
That’s not progress. That’s adaptation to toxicity. We’re treating the symptoms while ignoring the disease.
The FA deserves credit for those retention numbers. But we should be ashamed that they’re necessary. We’ve created an environment where the measure of success is “young people can now survive this” rather than “we’ve stopped adults from abusing young people.”
I know what needs to happen because I’ve been refereeing long enough to see what doesn’t work.
Clubs getting fined doesn’t solve this. The parents who explode don’t care if their club loses points or pays a penalty. That’s abstract to them. Someone else’s problem. They club will pay the fine and give them a stern talking-to, and they’ll be back on the touchline next week, telling themselves they’ve learned their lesson right up until the moment they lose it again.
The sanctions need to land on the actual perpetrators. The PCG who screamed at a 15-year-old needs a ban. Not a one-match slap on the wrist. A meaningful ban that makes them miss their child’s games. Make them explain to their kid why dad or mum etc. can’t come and watch anymore. Make the consequence personal and immediate.
Because right now, there aren’t any real consequences. Not for them. Just for the young referee who goes home thinking maybe this isn’t worth it. Just for grassroots football, which loses another official. Just for your child, who has fewer opportunities to play because we can’t recruit enough referees to cover the matches.
That nervous 15-year-old on the pitch isn’t the problem. They’re giving their weekend to enable your child’s football. They’re learning. They’re trying. They’re doing something most adults wouldn’t have the courage to do.
You – standing on the touchline deciding whether to explode or intervene or stay silent – you’re the problem.
Football isn’t bringing out the worst in you. You’re choosing to let it. Every time you lose control, every time you watch someone else lose control and say nothing, you’re making a choice about what kind of environment we’re building for young people.
These young referees will leave. Not all at once. Not dramatically. They’ll just quietly decide that giving up their weekends to be screamed at by adults isn’t worth it. And grassroots football will continue its slow collapse, one teenage referee at a time.
They are individuals who seem on the outset to be fairly rational, but football is bringing out the worst of them.
So here’s the question you need to answer for yourself: which one are you going to be?
The Secret Referee is an anonymous grassroots official sharing the realities of refereeing at every level of the game. These perspectives are based on years of experience on pitches across the country.
We’ve solved this problem and more with the FMHA Neurodiversity, Mental Health & Safeguarding Academy.
The FMHA Neurodiversity, Mental Health & Safeguarding Academy gives your entire club unlimited access to:
Not a one-off workshop. Not a Facebook group. An ongoing support system built specifically for grassroots football.
>> CLICK HERE FOR MORE INFO ON THE ACADEMY <<
LISTEN TO THIS ARTICLE BELOW:
The resources and support provided in The Vault are designed to promote mental wellbeing and provide general guidance on mental health related to grassroots football.
However, the content is not intended to serve as specific mental health advice or replace consultation with a trained professional. If you or someone you know requires personalised mental health support, we strongly encourage you to consult with a licensed mental health professional and/or seek appropriate services in your area.
